Connect with us

News & Analysis

Regional and National Legal and Policy Framework for Low Carbon Development

Published

on

Photo Courtesy: UNDP

By Hon. Prof. Kariuki Muigua, OGW, PhD, C.Arb, FCIArb is a Professor of Environmental Law and Dispute Resolution at the University of Nairobi, Member of Permanent Court of Arbitration, Leading Environmental Law Scholar, Respected Sustainable Development Policy Advisor, Top Natural Resources Lawyer, Highly-Regarded Dispute Resolution Expert and Awardee of the Order of Grand Warrior (OGW) of Kenya by H.E. the President of Republic of Kenya. He is The African ADR Practitioner of the Year 2022, The African Arbitrator of the Year 2022, ADR Practitioner of the Year in Kenya 2021, CIArb (Kenya) Lifetime Achievement Award 2021 and ADR Publisher of the Year 2021 and Author of the Kenya’s First ESG Book: Embracing Environmental Social and Governance (ESG) tenets for Sustainable Development” (Glenwood, Nairobi, July 2023) and Kenya’s First Two Climate Change Law Book: Combating Climate Change for Sustainability (Glenwood, Nairobi, October 2023) and Achieving Climate Justice for Development (Glenwood, Nairobi, October 2023)*

At the regional level, the East African Community Climate Change Policy recognizes the adverse impacts of climate change as a major challenge to socio-economic development globally. The Policy is aimed at contributing to Sustainable Development in the East African Community region through harmonized and coordinated regional strategies, programmes and actions to respond to climate change. It further seeks to address the adverse impacts of climate change in the region and harness any potential opportunities posed by climate change in the context of the principle of Sustainable Development. The Policy also seeks to support the integration of climate change into regional development processes and planning including disaster risk management and gender development among other targets.

Towards fostering low carbon development in the region, the Policy emphasizes the importance of mainstreaming climate change adaptation and mitigation into national and regional development plans, taking a sectoral approach, with an emphasis on key socio-economic sectors and sub-sectors adversely impacted by climate change and with potential opportunities to contribute to mitigation efforts and Sustainable Development of the East African region. These sectors include, but are not limited to: water resources, agriculture and food security (crop, livestock, fisheries production), energy, biodiversity and ecosystem services (forests, wildlife, wetlands, coastal and marine ecosystems), land use and soil protection, human health, tourism, industry, transport and infrastructure, disaster risk management, gender and community development, education, training and research and development.

The Policy also acknowledges that climate change mitigation presents an opportunity for East Africa to benefit from project activities that result in Certified Emission Reductions (CERs) under the CDM as provided for under the Kyoto Protocol to the UNFCCC or under similar provisions of any other future agreement. It further acknowledges that CDM can foster Sustainable Development in the region while at the same time contributing to the ultimate objective of the UNFCCC which is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and further assisting the region in securing funding of certified project activities within the sectors with significant mitigation such as energy, forestry, agriculture, waste management and transport.

In addition, the Policy urges East African countries to exploit opportunities in Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD) and REDD+ through a suite of relevant policies for conservation and sustainable management of forests and enhancement of forest carbon stocks. The Policy is vital in enhancing low carbon development in the East African region since it recognizes the critical need for the development of climate change adaptation and mitigation strategies to secure economic growth, social development and environmental sustainability of the region.  Actualizing this Policy is crucial in enhancing low carbon development in the region.

Enhancing low carbon development is also a pertinent objective under the climate change agenda in Kenya as envisioned under the Climate Change Act. The Act seeks to provide for a regulatory framework for enhanced response to climate change; to provide for mechanism and measures to achieve low carbon climate development among other purposes. The Act has since been amended by the Climate Change (Amendment) Act, 2023 in order to enhance climate change mitigation and adaption measures in Kenya.

The Amendment Act introduces the idea of carbon trading in Kenya and defines a carbon market as a mechanism that enables and allows public and private entities to transfer and transact emission reduction units, mitigation outcomes or offsets generated through carbon initiatives, programmes and projects subject to compliance of national and international laws. It also introduces the idea of carbon offset which refers to a reduction or removal of emissions of carbon dioxide or other greenhouse gases made in order to compensate for emissions made elsewhere. The Amended Act further requires national and county governments to provide guidance in the development and implementation of carbon markets and nonmarket approaches in compliance with international obligations.

Part IV A of the Amended Act provides the framework for the regulation of carbon markets in Kenya. It requires the state to formulate a policy direction on carbon markets which should prescribe carbon reduction credits that aim to reduce emissions from current sources through projects, removal or sequestration credits that take carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere and either use or store it via afforestation, reforestation, nature-based solutions or technology-based removal and technologies and projects towards this end. The Act requires the trade in carbon markets in Kenya to ensure that transactions in carbon trading aim towards a reduction of greenhouse gas emissions as per the prescribed carbon standards. The Act envisions the participation in carbon markets through bilateral or multilateral trading agreement, trading with private entities and voluntary carbon markets.

Towards this end, the Act gives the Cabinet Secretary in charge of the Ministry of Environment, Climate Change and Forestry power to enter into a bilateral or multilateral agreement with another state party to trade carbon for emission reductions and removals. In pursuance of the principles of Sustainable Development, the Act requires every carbon trading project authorized to undergo an Environmental and Social Impact Assessment in accordance Environmental Management and Coordination Act, 1999. It also requires every carbon project undertaken pursuant to the Act to take into consideration and aim to improve the economic, social and cultural wellbeing of the community around the project.

The amended Climate Change Act is an important milestone in fostering low carbon development in Kenya by providing the legal framework for carbon trading. Although the Climate Change Act, 2016 was intended to enhance national response to climate change and provided mechanisms and measures to achieve low carbon climate resilient development, it did not envisage the concept of carbon trading. The Amended Act has the potential to facilitate the effective implementation of carbon markets and trading making it possible for Kenya to engage a broader range of stakeholders and support its emissions reduction goals.

It has been pointed out that if well designed, carbon markets can be an effective, credible and transparent tool for helping to achieve low-cost emissions reductions in ways that mobilize private sector actors, attract investment, and encourage international cooperation. A price on carbon makes clean energy more profitable, allows energy efficiency to earn a greater return, makes low carbon products more competitive, and values the carbon stored in forests. The amended Climate Change Act can therefore usher in an era of low carbon development in Kenya by incorporating carbon markets and participation in them as a way to enhance national response to climate change.

Enhancing low carbon development in Kenya is also a priority under the Energy Act and the National Climate Change Action Plan (NCCAP) 2023-2027. The Energy Act requires the state to take measures towards harnessing opportunities offered under CDM and other mechanisms including, but not limited to, carbon credit trading to promote the development and exploitation of renewable energy sources. The NCCAP seeks to enhance low carbon development through measures such as developing carbon market frameworks for climate change adaptation and mitigation programs and providing incentives for investments in carbon markets and developing and operationalizing ecosystem and carbon benefit sharing framework.

The NCCAP outlines key priority climate action areas, with adaptation and mitigation actions across policy and regulatory environments; capacity building; knowledge management; technology and innovation; climate finance; and monitoring; reporting and verification. Kenya has therefore adopted an ambitious plan towards enhancing low carbon development. Enhancing low carbon development in Kenya is necessary in meeting the country’s NDC target of a 32% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2030. From the foregoing, it is evident that there are global, regional and national efforts towards enhancing low carbon development for sustainability.

*This is an extract from the Book: Achieving Climate Justice for Development (Glenwood Publishers, Nairobi, October 2023) by Hon. Prof.  Kariuki Muigua, OGW, PhD, Professor of Environmental Law and Dispute Resolution, Senior Advocate of Kenya, Chartered Arbitrator, Kenya’s ADR Practitioner of the Year 2021 (Nairobi Legal Awards), ADR Lifetime Achievement Award 2021 (CIArb Kenya), African Arbitrator of the Year 2022, Africa ADR Practitioner of the Year 2022, Member of National Environment Tribunal (NET) Emeritus (2017 to 2022) and Member of Permanent Court of Arbitration nominated by Republic of Kenya. Prof. Kariuki Muigua is a foremost Environmental Law and Natural Resources Lawyer and Scholar, Sustainable Development Advocate and Conflict Management Expert in Kenya. Prof. Kariuki Muigua teaches Environmental Law and Dispute resolution at the University of Nairobi School of Law, The Center for Advanced Studies in Environmental Law and Policy (CASELAP) and Wangari Maathai Institute for Peace and Environmental Studies. He has published numerous books and articles on Environmental Law, Environmental Justice Conflict Management, Alternative Dispute Resolution and Sustainable Development. Prof. Muigua is also a Chartered Arbitrator, an Accredited Mediator, the Managing Partner of Kariuki Muigua & Co. Advocates and Africa Trustee Emeritus of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators 2019-2022. Prof. Muigua is a 2023 recipient of President of the Republic of Kenya Order of Grand Warrior (OGW) Award for his service to the Nation as a Distinguished Expert, Academic and Scholar in Dispute Resolution and recognized among the top 5 leading lawyers and dispute resolution experts in Band 1 in Kenya by the Chambers Global Guide 2022 and was listed in the Inaugural THE LAWYER AFRICA Litigation Hall of Fame 2023 as one of the Top 50 Most Distinguished Litigation Lawyers in Kenya and the Top Arbitrator in Kenya in 2023.

References

Almomani. S., ‘Climate Justice for People with Disabilities.’ Available at https://www.worldforgottenchildren.org/blog/climate-justice-for-people-with-disabilities/154 (Accessed on 29/07/2023).

Brower. A., ‘Fighting Climate Injustice: 10 Strategies for Action.’ Available at https://www.gensler.com/blog/fighting-climate-injustice-10-strategies-for-action (Accessed on 29/07/2023).

Climate Change Act, No. 11 of 2016, Laws of Kenya, Government Printer, Nairobi.

Climate Change Act, No. 11 of 2016, Laws of Kenya.

East African Community., ‘East African Community Climate Change Policy.’ Available at https://www.eac.int/environment/climate-change/eac-climate-change-policyframework (Accessed on 07/09/2023).

European Environment Agency., ‘What is the Difference between Adaptation and Mitigation?’ Available at https://www.eea.europa.eu/help/faq/what-is-the-differencebetween#:~:text=In%20essence%2C%20adaptation%20can%20be,(GHG)%20into%20the% 20atmosphere (Accessed on 07/09/2023)

Fragkos. P et al., ‘Energy System Impacts and Policy Implications of the European Intended Nationally Determined Contribution and Low-Carbon Pathway to 2050.’ Energy Policy 100 (2017) 216–226.

Hugel. S., & Davies. A., ‘Public Participation, Engagement, and Climate Change Adaptation: A Review of the Research Literature.’ WIREs Climate Change, 2020.

Kipkemoi. F., ‘Key Highlights of Amended Climate Change Act.’ Available at https://www.the-star.co.ke/news/realtime/2023-09-01-key-highlights-of-amended-climatechange-act/ (Accessed on 07/09/2023).

Mace. M., ‘Mitigation Commitments under the Paris Agreement and the Way Forward.’ Climate Law, No. 6 of 2016, pp 21-39 39 European Bank for Reconstruction and Development., ‘The Paris Agreement.’ Available at https://www.ebrd.com/paris-agreement (Accessed on 29/07/2023).

Ministry of Environment, Climate Change and Forestry., ‘Draft Strategic Plan: 2023- 2027’ Available at https://www.environment.go.ke/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/MoECCFStrategic-Plan-Draft-07.05.2023-updated.pdf (Accessed on 07/09/2023)

Muigua. K., ‘Redefining the Role of Lawyers in Climate Justice.’ Available at http://kmco.co.ke/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Redefining-the-Role-of-Lawyers-in-ClimateJustice-.pdf (Accessed on 29/07/2023).

NASA., ‘Responding to Climate Change.’ Available at https://climate.nasa.gov/solutions/adaptationmitigation/#:~:text=Responding%20to%20climate%20change%20involves%20two%20poss ible%20approaches%3A%20reducing%20and,pipeline%20(%E2%80%9Cadaptation%E2% 80%9D) (Accessed on 07/09/2023).

Natural Justice., ‘Kenya’s Climate Change Bill: Paving the Way for Sustainable Development and Carbon Markets.’ Available at https://naturaljustice.org/kenyas- climate-change-bill-paving-the-way-for-sustainable-development-and-carbon-markets/ (Accessed on 07/09/2023).

United Nations Children’s Fund., ‘What is Climate Justice? And what can we do Achieve It?’ Available at https://www.unicef.org/globalinsight/what-climate-justice-andwhat-can-we-do-achieve-it (Accessed on 29/07/2023).

United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific., ‘LowCarbon Development Plan.’ Available at https://www.unescap.org/sites/default/files/45.%20FS-Low-Carbon-Development-Plan.pdf (Accessed on 07/09/2023).

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, ‘Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.’ Available at https://unfccc.int/resource/docs/convkp/kpeng.pdf (Accessed on 07/09/2023).

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, United Nations, 1992., Available at https://unfccc.int/resource/docs/convkp/conveng.pdf (Accessed on 07/09/2023).

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change., ‘China’s Achievements, New Goals and New Measures for Nationally Determined Contributions.’ Available at https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/NDC/202206/China%E2%80%99s%20Achievements% 2C%20New%20Goals%20and%20New%20Measures%20for%20Nationally%20Determine d%20Contributions.pdf (Accessed on 29/07/2023).

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change., ‘Introduction to Gender and Climate Change.’ Available at https://unfccc.int/gender (Accessed on 29/07/2023).

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change., ‘Paris Agreement.’ Available at https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/english_paris_agreement.pdf (Accessed on 07/09/2023).

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change., ‘The Kyoto Protocol Mechanisms.’ Available at https://cdm.unfccc.int/about/cdm_kpm.pdf (Accessed on 07/09/2023).

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change., ‘The United States of America Nationally Determined Contribution.’ Available at https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/NDC/202206/United%20States%20NDC%20April%20 21%202021%20Final.pdf (Accessed on 29/07/2023)

United Nations., ‘Low Carbon Development.’ Available at https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/index.php?menu=1448#:~:text=The%20concept%20o f%20low%20carbon,low%2Dcarbon%20growth%20plans (Accessed on 07/09/2023)

Xin. X, Yuding. W, & Jianzhong. W., ‘The Problems and Strategies of the Low Carbon Economy Development.’ Energy Procedia 5 (2011) 1831–1836.

Yuan. H, Zhou. P, & Zhou. D., ‘What is Low-Carbon Development? A Conceptual Analysis.’ Energy Procedia, 5 (2011) 1706–1712.

News & Analysis

The Nexus between Environmental Social and Governance (ESG) and Arbitration

Published

on

By

By Hon. Prof. Kariuki Muigua, OGW, PhD, C.Arb, FCIArb is a Professor of Environmental Law and Dispute Resolution at the University of Nairobi, Member of Permanent Court of Arbitration, Leading Environmental Law Scholar, Respected Sustainable Development Policy Advisor, Top Natural Resources Lawyer, Highly-Regarded Dispute Resolution Expert and Awardee of the Order of Grand Warrior (OGW) of Kenya by H.E. the President of Republic of Kenya. He is the Academic Champion of ADR 2024, the African ADR Practitioner of the Year 2022, the African Arbitrator of the Year 2022, ADR Practitioner of the Year in Kenya 2021, CIArb (Kenya) Lifetime Achievement Award 2021 and ADR Publisher of the Year 2021 and Author of the Kenya’s First ESG Book: Embracing Environmental Social and Governance (ESG) tenets for Sustainable Development” (Glenwood, Nairobi, July 2023) and Kenya’s First Two Climate Change Law Book: Combating Climate Change for Sustainability (Glenwood, Nairobi, October 2023), Achieving Climate Justice for Development (Glenwood, Nairobi, October 2023) and Promoting Rule of Law for Sustainable Development (Glenwood, Nairobi, January 2024)*

Arbitration is form of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanisms. ADR refers to a set of mechanisms that are applied in management of disputes without resort to adversarial litigation. It has been described as a private and consensual process where parties to a dispute agree to present their grievances to a third party for resolution. It is argued that ESG principles have become a model for sustainable business development through which a corporations’ goal for solving environmental, social and governance problems is achieved. Consequently, ESG considerations have an increasing impact in international business as evidenced by the incorporation of sustainability clauses in investment contracts. In such contracts, investors are required to adhere to the concept of sustainable development as envisaged under the contracts and failure to do so may result in ESG related disputes.

In the wake of the climate change debate, there have been calls for responsible business practice towards climate change mitigation through measures such as reduction of carbon emissions. The Paris Agreement on Climate Change has raised the awareness of the need for global efforts to combat climate change and the role of responsible and ethical corporate behavior towards achieving this goal. Further, corporations are increasingly required to safeguard human rights as envisaged by ‘S’ pillar of ESG.

However, some corporations have been accused of violating these ESG concerns as a result of their business practices. Some corporations have been accused of failing to promote climate change mitigation through reduction of carbon emissions and transitioning to cleaner energy production. Further, some corporations have been accused of violating fundamental human rights such as the right to a clean and healthy environment especially in the investment sphere in Africa. These instances have resulted in an increasing number of ESG-related disputes. The growth of ESG concerns has seen corporations being increasingly required to embrace ESG principles in their business practices. Consequently, ESG clauses are being adopted in commercial and investment contracts.

In case of violation of such clauses, ESG related disputes are bound to occur. It has been asserted that adoption of ESG related practices into pre-existing social and governance models adopted by corporations would be disruptive. The inclusion of ESG clauses in commercial contracts not only points to the importance of ESG concerns to companies but it also serves as potential source of disputes where such considerations are not complied with. ESG issues are not only reshaping corporate behavior across the globe but can also be a potential battleground in international disputes25. This creates the need for an effective mechanism of management of such disputes in order to enhance ESG principles in the quest for Sustainable Development.

Arbitration has for a long time been the most viable mechanism for management of international commercial and investment disputes. It offers a neutral forum for the management of disputes and addresses some of the concerns that parties may have in relation to the other parties’ legal system. In international commercial and investment arbitration, parties are reluctant to submit to the jurisdiction of the other party due to the likelihood of favoritism by the host judicial system. Further, arbitration has the potential of facilitating expeditious management of disputes.

In international commercial and investment arbitration, there is need to manage disputes expeditiously in order to preserve the commercial interests of parties. The viability of arbitration in management of international commercial disputes is further enhanced by the availability of a legal framework for the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards. The New York Convention provides the legal framework for the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards across different jurisdictions. Consequently, the adoption of ESG elements in international commercial and investment agreements has resulted in the use of arbitration to manage disputes arising from such agreements.

ESG concerns have become prominent in investor-state arbitration with arbitral tribunals having to determine issues relating to climate change, corruption and human rights. It has been asserted that the growth of ESG will redefine the practice of arbitration as it seeks to adapt to the new concerns created by ESG. However, the flexibility of arbitration and its ability to adapt to emerging concerns means that it is well positioned to manage ESG disputes. However, there is need for reform in order to enhance the role of arbitration in managing ESG disputes.

*This article is an abridged version of the Article The Place of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) in Arbitration (Available for download at Kariuki Muigua & Co. Advocates Website, follow the link) by Hon. Prof.  Kariuki Muigua, OGW, PhD, Professor of Environmental Law and Dispute Resolution, Senior Advocate of Kenya, Chartered Arbitrator, Kenya’s ADR Practitioner of the Year 2021 (Nairobi Legal Awards), ADR Lifetime Achievement Award 2021 (CIArb Kenya), African Arbitrator of the Year 2022, Africa ADR Practitioner of the Year 2022, Member of National Environment Tribunal (NET) Emeritus (2017 to 2023) and Member of Permanent Court of Arbitration nominated by Republic of Kenya and Academic Champion of ADR 2024. Prof. Kariuki Muigua is a foremost Environmental Law and Natural Resources Lawyer and Scholar, Sustainable Development Advocate and Conflict Management Expert in Kenya. Prof. Kariuki Muigua teaches Environmental Law and Dispute resolution at the University of Nairobi School of Law, The Center for Advanced Studies in Environmental Law and Policy (CASELAP) and Wangari Maathai Institute for Peace and Environmental Studies. He has published numerous books and articles on Environmental Law, Environmental Justice Conflict Management, Alternative Dispute Resolution and Sustainable Development. Prof. Muigua is also a Chartered Arbitrator, an Accredited Mediator, the Managing Partner of Kariuki Muigua & Co. Advocates and Africa Trustee Emeritus of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators 2019-2022. Prof. Muigua is a 2023 recipient of President of the Republic of Kenya Order of Grand Warrior (OGW) Award for his service to the Nation as a Distinguished Expert, Academic and Scholar in Dispute Resolution and recognized among the top 5 leading lawyers and dispute resolution experts in Band 1 in Kenya by the Chambers Global Guide 2024 and was listed in the Inaugural THE LAWYER AFRICA Litigation Hall of Fame 2023 as one of the Top 50 Most Distinguished Litigation Lawyers in Kenya and the Top Arbitrator in Kenya in 2023.

Hamilton. J & Coulet-Diaz. M., ‘Arbitration & the ESG Era’ available at https://www.whitecase.com/news/media/arbitration-esg-era (accessed on 28/09/2022).

International Arbitration in 2022., ‘The Rising Significance of ESG and the Role of International Arbitration’ available at https://www.freshfields.com/en-gb/our-thinking/campaigns/internationalarbitration-in-2022/the-rising-significance-of-esg-and-the-role-of-international-arbitration/ (accessed on 28/09/2022)

Mazhorina. M.V., ‘ESG Principles in International Business and Sustainable Contracts’ available at https://aprp.msal.ru/jour/article/view/3223?locale=en_US (accessed on 28/09/2022).

Moses. L.M, ‘The Principles and Practice of International Commercial Arbitration’ 2 nd Edition, 2017, Cambridge University Press 28 Ibid 29Muigua. K., ‘Promoting International Commercial Arbitration in Africa’ available at http://kmco.co.ke/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/PROMOTING-INTERNATIONAL-COMMERCIALARBITRATION-IN-AFRICA.pdf

Muigua. K., ‘International Investment Law and Policy in Africa: Human Rights, Environmental Damage and Sustainable Development’ available at http://kmco.co.ke/wpcontent/uploads/2018/11/International-Investment-Law-and-Policy-in-Africa-AILA-Conference-Paper5-11-2018.pdf (accessed on 28/09/2022)

Muigua. K., ‘Realising Environmental, Social and Governance Tenets for Sustainable Development’ available at http://kmco.co.ke/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Realising-Environmental-Social-andGovernance-Tenets-of-Sustainable-Development-Kariuki-Muigua-July-2022.pdf (accessed on 28/09/2022)

Muigua. K., ‘Settling Disputes Through Arbitration in Kenya’ Glenwood Publishers Limited, 4th Edition, 2022

Ross. A., ‘We need talk about ESG’ available at https://globalarbitrationreview.com/we-need-talkabout-esg (accessed on 28/09/2022)

The ALP Review., ‘The Importance of ESG and its effect on International Arbitration’ available at https://www.alp.company/sites/default/files/ALP%20Review%20- %20The%20Importance%20of%20ESG %20and%20its%20effect%20on%20International%20Arbitration.pdf (accessed on 28/09/2022).

United Nations Conference on International Commercial Arbitration, ‘Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards’ United Nations, 1958

Von Wobeser., ‘The Role of Arbitration in ESG Disputes’ available at https://www.vonwobeser.com/index.php/publication?p_id=1650 (accessed on 28/09/2022)

Continue Reading

News & Analysis

Enhancing the Role of Arbitration in Management of ESG Disputes

Published

on

By

By Hon. Prof. Kariuki Muigua, OGW, PhD, C.Arb, FCIArb is a Professor of Environmental Law and Dispute Resolution at the University of Nairobi, Member of Permanent Court of Arbitration, Leading Environmental Law Scholar, Respected Sustainable Development Policy Advisor, Top Natural Resources Lawyer, Highly-Regarded Dispute Resolution Expert and Awardee of the Order of Grand Warrior (OGW) of Kenya by H.E. the President of Republic of Kenya. He is the Academic Champion of ADR 2024, the African ADR Practitioner of the Year 2022, the African Arbitrator of the Year 2022, ADR Practitioner of the Year in Kenya 2021, CIArb (Kenya) Lifetime Achievement Award 2021 and ADR Publisher of the Year 2021 and Author of the Kenya’s First ESG Book: Embracing Environmental Social and Governance (ESG) tenets for Sustainable Development” (Glenwood, Nairobi, July 2023) and Kenya’s First Two Climate Change Law Book: Combating Climate Change for Sustainability (Glenwood, Nairobi, October 2023), Achieving Climate Justice for Development (Glenwood, Nairobi, October 2023) and Promoting Rule of Law for Sustainable Development (Glenwood, Nairobi, January 2024)*

Arbitration represents a viable mechanism for management of ESG disputes. The following are proposals for interventions towards embracing arbitration in management of ESG disputes for Sustainable Development towards enhancing the use of arbitration in ESG disputes:

Enhancing Knowledge in ESG Concerns

Statistics show that many ESG related disputes are being managed through arbitration. According to the International Chamber of Commerce, engineering, construction and energy disputes represent the highest number of cases handled representing 38% of all cases registered so far. Such disputes entail ESG components such as renewable energy projects, environmental protection and human rights concerns. This demonstrates that ESG and arbitration are inextricably linked. Arbitration practitioners thus need to equip themselves with knowledge in ESG related matters in order to be better placed to manage ESG related disputes.

Promoting Sustainable Development

Sustainable Development has been defined as development that meets the needs of the present generation without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. This concept entails a combination of elements including environmental protection, economic development and social issues. The importance of Sustainable Development has seen the adoption of the Sustainable Development Goals as the global blueprint of development. Most of the Sustainable Development Goals entail aspects of ESG such as clean water and sanitation, affordable and clean energy, industry, innovation and infrastructure and climate action. Arbitration practitioners should therefore promote the principles of sustainable development when managing ESG related disputes. This could entail requiring investors to comply with the host country environmental laws and ESG standards in mining, energy and construction disputes which have an ESG bearing.

Upholding Human Rights

The ‘S’ pillar in ESG seeks to promote responsible and ethical corporate behavior through aspects such as respect for human rights. However, corporate behavior especially in the investment sphere in Africa has resulted in gross violation of human rights. Some corporations which have invested in oil exploration have been accused of human right abuses, environmental degradation and unsustainable peace due to their business culture. In Kenya, a multinational corporation that has invested in the agricultural sector has been accused of human right abuses such as killings, rape, and other forms of sexual and gender-based violence allegedly committed by its guards, bad labour practices and land injustices against the neighbouring communities. Some of these disputes have ended up in arbitration where tribunals are called upon to adjudicate on human rights issues. Arbitrators should thus seek to uphold human rights in such disputes by rendering awards that are in line with human rights standards. By promoting human rights, arbitrators will be embracing the ‘S’ pillar that is fundamental in the ESG debate.

Promoting Good Governance

The Governance pillar in ESG seeks to achieve good financial and accounting standards as well as legal and regulatory compliance, such as transparency, corporate structures and ethics in corporate conduct. It also seeks to align Governance with the Sustainable Development Goals where governance issues include industry, innovation and infrastructure (Goal 9); peace, justice and strong institutions (Goal 16); and partnerships with public and private institutions (Goal 17). Good governance can be promoted through arbitration by rendering awards that adhere to good governance practices such as transparency, accountability, reporting and disclosure.

Seeking Expert Assistance in Complex ESG Matters

Arbitration has a significant role in promoting ESG tenets in areas such as climate change. Arbitrators play a significant role in shaping and adapting international law to respond to the climate crisis. However, in some instances, arbitration has been slow to act to act in response to the climate crisis. Some climate change concerns such as determining adherence to climate change commitments through low carbon transition requires arbitrators to be fully informed and engaged in such concepts. This may require expert analysis and guidance from persons with requisite knowledge in environmental matters. Arbitrators should therefore seek expert assistance in such issues in order to be fully informed and render awards that promote ESG principles.

Conclusion

The relationship between Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) and arbitration continues to grow. Adoption of ESG by corporations as a means of promoting responsible and ethical business practices and the wide use of arbitration in management of international commercial and investment disputes points to increased use of arbitration in management of ESG related disputes. In managing such disputes, arbitrators should promote ESG considerations whilst balancing the needs and interests of parties involved in issues such as climate change. Arbitration represents a viable mechanism for managing ESG disputes while simultaneously promoting Sustainable Development. There is need to enhance the viability of arbitration in management of ESG related disputes.

*This article is an abridged version of the Article The Place of Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) in Arbitration by Hon. Prof.  Kariuki Muigua, OGW, PhD, Professor of Environmental Law and Dispute Resolution, Senior Advocate of Kenya, Chartered Arbitrator, Kenya’s ADR Practitioner of the Year 2021 (Nairobi Legal Awards), ADR Lifetime Achievement Award 2021 (CIArb Kenya), African Arbitrator of the Year 2022, Africa ADR Practitioner of the Year 2022, Member of National Environment Tribunal (NET) Emeritus (2017 to 2023) and Member of Permanent Court of Arbitration nominated by Republic of Kenya and Academic Champion of ADR 2024. Prof. Kariuki Muigua is a foremost Environmental Law and Natural Resources Lawyer and Scholar, Sustainable Development Advocate and Conflict Management Expert in Kenya. Prof. Kariuki Muigua teaches Environmental Law and Dispute resolution at the University of Nairobi School of Law, The Center for Advanced Studies in Environmental Law and Policy (CASELAP) and Wangari Maathai Institute for Peace and Environmental Studies. He has published numerous books and articles on Environmental Law, Environmental Justice Conflict Management, Alternative Dispute Resolution and Sustainable Development. Prof. Muigua is also a Chartered Arbitrator, an Accredited Mediator, the Managing Partner of Kariuki Muigua & Co. Advocates and Africa Trustee Emeritus of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators 2019-2022. Prof. Muigua is a 2023 recipient of President of the Republic of Kenya Order of Grand Warrior (OGW) Award for his service to the Nation as a Distinguished Expert, Academic and Scholar in Dispute Resolution and recognized among the top 5 leading lawyers and dispute resolution experts in Band 1 in Kenya by the Chambers Global Guide 2024 and was listed in the Inaugural THE LAWYER AFRICA Litigation Hall of Fame 2023 as one of the Top 50 Most Distinguished Litigation Lawyers in Kenya and the Top Arbitrator in Kenya in 2023.

References

Amao. O., ‘Corporate Social Responsibility, Human Rights and the Law: Multinational corporations in Developing Countries.’ Routledge, 2011.

Cummins. T et al., ‘ESG Litigation – How Companies Can Get Ready, Respond and Resolve Claims’ available at https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/JOIC-07-2021-0032/full/html (accessed on 29/09/2022)

Fitzmaurice, M., ‘The Principle of Sustainable Development in International Development Law’ International Sustainable Development Law, Vol. 1.

Greenwood. L., ‘The Canary is Dead: Arbitration and Climate Change’ Journal of International Arbitration, Volume 38, Issue 3 (2021).

Miles. W., ‘BVI: A Frontline Focus for Resolving Future Climate Change Related Disputes’ available at https://www.bviiac. org/Portals/0/Files/Publications/Wendy%20 Miles %20QC_BVI_ A%20Frontline%20Focus%20for%20Resolving%20Future%20Climate%20Change%20Related %20Disputes.pdf (accessed on 29/09/2022)

Krajewski, M. ‘Human Rights in International Investment Law: Recent Trends in Arbitration and Treaty-Making Practice.’ Available at SSRN 3133529 (2018).

Maiangwa.B & Agbiboa.D., ‘Oil Multinational Corporations, Environmental Irresponsibility and Turbulent Peace in the Niger Delta’ Africa Spectrum 2/2013: 71-83

Kenya Human Rights Commission., ‘Heavy price for… egregious human rights violations’ available at https://www.khrc.or.ke/2015-03-04-10-37-01/press-releases/737-heavy-price-for-kakuzi-s-egregioushuman-rights-violations.html (accessed on 29/09/2022).

RL360, “Governance-The G in ESG,” Available at: https://www.rl360.com/row/funds/ investmentdefinitions/g-in-esg.htm (accessed on 29/09/2022)

Sustainable Development’ available at https://sdgs.un.org/goals (accessed on 29/09/2022)

The ALP Review., ‘The Importance of ESG and its effect on International Arbitration’ available at https://www.alp.company/sites/default/files/ALP%20Review%20- %20The%20Importance%20of%20ESG %20and%20its%20effect %20on%20International%20Arbitration.pdf

United Nations., ‘Sustainable Development Goals’ available at https://sdgs.un.org/goals (accessed on 28/09/2022)

World Commission on Environment and Development, Our Common future. Oxford, (Oxford University Press, 1987).

Continue Reading

News & Analysis

Way Forward in Managing Risk and Liability of ESG Litigation

Published

on

By

By Hon. Prof. Kariuki Muigua, OGW, PhD, C.Arb, FCIArb is a Professor of Environmental Law and Dispute Resolution at the University of Nairobi, Member of Permanent Court of Arbitration, Leading Environmental Law Scholar, Respected Sustainable Development Policy Advisor, Top Natural Resources Lawyer, Highly-Regarded Dispute Resolution Expert and Awardee of the Order of Grand Warrior (OGW) of Kenya by H.E. the President of Republic of Kenya. He is the Academic Champion of ADR 2024, the African ADR Practitioner of the Year 2022, the African Arbitrator of the Year 2022, ADR Practitioner of the Year in Kenya 2021, CIArb (Kenya) Lifetime Achievement Award 2021 and ADR Publisher of the Year 2021 and Author of the Kenya’s First ESG Book: Embracing Environmental Social and Governance (ESG) tenets for Sustainable Development” (Glenwood, Nairobi, July 2023) and Kenya’s First Two Climate Change Law Book: Combating Climate Change for Sustainability (Glenwood, Nairobi, October 2023), Achieving Climate Justice for Development (Glenwood, Nairobi, October 2023) and Promoting Rule of Law for Sustainable Development (Glenwood, Nairobi, January 2024)*

In order for companies to manage the risk and liability associated with ESG litigation, it is imperative for them to strengthen their ESG reporting and disclosure requirements. It has been observed that recent ESG trends have driven the requirement by businesses to report on ESG aspects such as human rights and environmental standards as evidenced by emerging legal frameworks requiring companies to report on human rights and environmental issues, emerging mandatory human rights due diligence legislation, and increased legal enforcement and litigation risks.

As a result, it is important for companies to treat public disclosures in relation to ESG matters seriously and consider taking independent auditing and verification steps, particularly for annual ESG-related reports and/or other material ESG disclosures. Such an approach can help companies effectively manage and reduce the risk of ESG related litigation.

In addition, it has been argued that there is need for companies to embrace best practices in order to mitigate the risks of ESG litigation and also address such litigation when it arises. For example, it has been suggested that companies should conduct risk assessments in order to determine the likelihood of ESG related suits and deal with such concerns immediately; undertake public engagement to order to ensure openness and transparency in ESG matters; build knowledge on ESG issues in order to be well equipped to handle ESG claims when they arise; and strengthen their management systems and internal practices in order to enhance compliance with ESG standards.

It has been observed that ESG litigation is associated with several risks to companies including regulatory and enforcement risk, reputational risk, damage to brand, potential disruption by activists and financial risks such as loss of access to capital and financial losses as a result of damages, fines and other forms of monetary compensation. It is also imperative to strengthen access to justice in ESG matters. It has been pointed out that in order for litigants to be given the right of access to courts in ESG matters, whether individually, collectively, or as a third party or amicus curiae, the criteria pertaining to standing, which differ from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, must be followed.

It is also necessary to widen and strengthen the jurisdiction of courts on ESG issues such as climate change. Further, it has been pointed out that there is need to embrace techniques such as litigation funding in order to provide the financial stability and support needed to pursue legal action without compromising on the quality of representation or legal strategy in ESG matters. It has been argued that litigation funding can be an effective strategy for needy claimants to pursue claims against a company that they may ordinarily not be able to afford, enabling them to ultimately to hold companies to account for ESG failures.

Finally, it is imperative for companies to think creatively and strategically in order to effectively resolve ESG claims. It has been pointed out that ESG claims may significantly differ from other types of litigation companies have previously faced, hence the need for creative solutions towards these claims. For example, in ESG claims, there is need to bear in mind both the litigation aspects of a dispute, and broader ESG concerns including those around reputation and access to capital. As a result, it has been suggested that there is need for companies to be alive to the potential for resolving ESG claims outside the court room, and what mitigation strategies could be deployed to avoid litigation.

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) mechanisms are ideal in managing ESG disputes by fostering privacy, cost effective and expeditious management of disputes while also allowing parties to select experts to hear and determine contentious ESG matters. In addition, it has correctly been observed that businesses would normally prefer to have their disputes managed in a private manner in order to prevent ruining their image in public and also in an expeditious and cost-effective manner in order to protect business interests.

It has also been pointed out that the use of ADR mechanisms such as mediation in managing ESG related disputes is a practical demonstration of a sustainability-oriented business culture since mediation can offer a quick, flexible, consensual and win-win solution based on the mutually accepted interests of the parties. ADR mechanisms can therefore be an effective tool to enable companies manage the risks associated with ESG litigation.

*This is an extract from the Article: Fostering Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) Litigation for Sustainability, Available at: https://kmco.co.ke/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Fostering-Environmental-Social-and-Governance-ESG-Litigation-for-Sustainability.pdf (Accessed 2nd March 2024) by Hon. Prof.  Kariuki Muigua, OGW, PhD, Professor of Environmental Law and Dispute Resolution, Senior Advocate of Kenya, Chartered Arbitrator, Kenya’s ADR Practitioner of the Year 2021 (Nairobi Legal Awards), ADR Lifetime Achievement Award 2021 (CIArb Kenya), African Arbitrator of the Year 2022, Africa ADR Practitioner of the Year 2022, Member of National Environment Tribunal (NET) Emeritus (2017 to 2023) and Member of Permanent Court of Arbitration nominated by Republic of Kenya and Academic Champion of ADR 2024. Prof. Kariuki Muigua is a foremost Environmental Law and Natural Resources Lawyer and Scholar, Sustainable Development Advocate and Conflict Management Expert in Kenya. Prof. Kariuki Muigua teaches Environmental Law and Dispute resolution at the University of Nairobi School of Law, The Center for Advanced Studies in Environmental Law and Policy (CASELAP) and Wangari Maathai Institute for Peace and Environmental Studies. He has published numerous books and articles on Environmental Law, Environmental Justice Conflict Management, Alternative Dispute Resolution and Sustainable Development. Prof. Muigua is also a Chartered Arbitrator, an Accredited Mediator, the Managing Partner of Kariuki Muigua & Co. Advocates and Africa Trustee Emeritus of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators 2019-2022. Prof. Muigua is a 2023 recipient of President of the Republic of Kenya Order of Grand Warrior (OGW) Award for his service to the Nation as a Distinguished Expert, Academic and Scholar in Dispute Resolution and recognized among the top 5 leading lawyers and dispute resolution experts in Band 1 in Kenya by the Chambers Global Guide 2024 and was listed in the Inaugural THE LAWYER AFRICA Litigation Hall of Fame 2023 as one of the Top 50 Most Distinguished Litigation Lawyers in Kenya and the Top Arbitrator in Kenya in 2023.

References

African Development Bank Group., ‘Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG).’ Available at https://www.afdb.org/en/topics-and-sectors/topics/environmental-social-and-governance-esg (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

Ahurst., ‘ESG Litigation – Get Ready Respond and Resolve.’ Available at https://www.ashurst.com/en/insights/esg-litigation—get-ready-respond-and-resolve/ (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

Banda ML and Fulton CS, ‘Litigating Climate Change in National Courts: Recent Trends and Developments in Global Climate Law’ (2017) 47 Environmental Law Reporter.

Barbosa. A et al., ‘Integration of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Criteria: Their Impacts on Corporate Sustainability Performance.’ Humanit Soc Sci Commun 10, 410 (2023). Available at https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-023-01919-0 (Accessed on 03/02/2024).

British Business Bank., ‘What is ESG – A Guide for Businesses.’ Available at https://www.britishbusiness-bank.co.uk/finance-hub/business-guidance/sustainability/what-is-esg-aguide-for-smallerbusinesses/ (Accessed on 03/02/2024).

Fitzmaurice. M., ‘The Principle of Sustainable Development in International Development Law.’ International Sustainable Development Law., Vol 1.

Giovannoni. E., & Fabietti. G., ‘What Is Sustainability? A Review of the Concept and Its Applications.’ In: Busco, C., Frigo, M., Riccaboni, A., Quattrone, P. (eds) Integrated Reporting. Springer, Cham. Available at https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-02168-3_2 (Accessed on 03/02/2024).

Global Campus of Human Rights., ‘Rethinking Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Investing for Successful Sustainability and Human Rights.’ Available at https://gchumanrights.org/gcpreparedness/preparedness-development/article-detail/rethinkingenviron mental-social-andgovernance-esg-investing-for-successful-sustainability-and-human-rights5039.html (Accessed on 05/03/2024).

Gramatidis.B & Emvalomenos. D., ‘Sustainability in Dispute Resolution -Mediation as an ESG Practice.’ Available at https://www.bahagram.com/sustainability-in-dispute-resolution-mediation-as-anesgpractice/ (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

Hackett. D et al., ‘Growing ESG Risks: The Rise of Litigation.’ Available at https://www.bakermckenzie.com/- /media/files/insight/publications/2020/10/growing_esg_risks _the_rise_of_litigation.pdf (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

Heinberg. R., ‘What Is Sustainability?.’ Available at https://cdn.auckland.ac.nz/assets/arts/documents/What%20is%20Sustainability.pdf (Accessed on 03/02/2024).

Kemp. B et al., ‘The Rise of ESG Litigation and Horizontal Human Rights Enforcement.’ Available at https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=07a94453-f2aa-490a-a7e1-f6c25256cbf9 (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

Latham & Watkins LLP., ‘ESG Litigation Roadmap.’ Available at https://www.lw.com/admin/upload/SiteAttachments/ESG-Litigation-Roadmap.pdf (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

Li. T., et al., ‘ESG: Research Progress and Future Prospects.’ Available at https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/0dd4/941ebea33330210daff5f37a1c8cdd0547d7.pdf (Accessed on 03/02/2024).’

Li. T., et al., ‘ESG: Research Progress and Future Prospects.’ Op Cit 24 Ahmad. H., Yaqub. M., & Lee. S. H., ‘Environmental-, Social-, and Governance-Related Factors for Business Investment and Sustainability: A Scientometric Review of Global Trends.’ Available at https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10668-023-02921 (Accessed on 03/02/2024).

Mathis. S., & Stedman. C., ‘Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG).’ Available at https://www.techtarget.com/whatis/definition/environmental-social-and-governanceESG#:~:text= Environmental%2C%20social%20and%20governance%20(ESG)%20is%20a%20framework%2 0used,and%20opportunities%20in%20those%20areas (Accessed on 03/02/2024).

May. S., & Radcliffe. M., ‘The Evolving ESG litigation Landscape.’ Available at https://www.grantthornton.co.uk/insights/the-evolving-esg-litigation-landscape/ (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

McKenzie. S., Philippides. M., & De. Meyer., ‘A Look to the Future: Litigation Risks Faced by the Financial Sector in Relation to ESG Statements.’ Available at https://www.investafrica.com/insights-/a-look-to-thefuture-litigation-risks-faced-by-the-financial-sector-in-relation-to-esg-statements (Accessed on 05/03/2024).

Mikhaeel. M., ‘How Human Rights Due Diligence Affects the ‘E’ in ESG.’ Available at https://www.financierworldwide.com/how-human-rights-due-diligence-affects-the-e-in-esg (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

Muigua. K., ‘(Re) Examining Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) and Human Rights.’ Available at https://kmco.co.ke/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Re-Examining-Environmental-Social-andGovernance-ESG-and-Human-Rights.pdf (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

Muigua. K., ‘Greenwashing: A Hindrance to Achieving Sustainability?’ Available at https://kmco.co.ke/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/Greenwashing-A-hindrance-to-AchievingSustainability -Kariuki-Muigua-August-2023.pdf (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

Muigua. K., ‘Promoting Climate Litigation in Kenya for Sustainability.’ Available at https://kmco.co.ke/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/Promoting-Climate-litigation-in-Kenya-forSustainability-Kariuki-Muigua-August-2023.pdf (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

Norton. C., ‘Growing ESG Litigation Is Advancing Thinking on New Practices Needed.’ Available at https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/growing-esg-litigation-advancing-thinking-new-practicesnorton?utm_source=share&utm_medium=member_android&utm_campaign=share_via (Accessed on 03/02/2024).

Peterdy. K., & Miller. N., ‘What is ESG?’ Available at https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/esg/esg-environmental-social-governance (Accessed on 03/02/2024).

Runyon. N., ‘How Litigation Funding Drives Progress in the ESG Agenda.’ Available at https://www.thomsonreuters.com/en-us/posts/esg/litigation-funding-esgagenda/#:~:text=A%20driving %20force %20in%20access%20to%20justice&text=Litigation%20funding%2 0also%20provides%20the,of %20representation%20or%20legal%20strategy. (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

Stuart. L.G et al., ‘Firms and Social Responsibility: A Review of ESG and CSR Research in Corporate Finance.’ Journal of Corporate Finance 66 (2021): 101889.

Thailand Arbitration Center., ‘Alternative Dispute Resolution: Significance of ESG in Arbitration.’ Available at https://thac.or.th/alternative-dispute-resolution-significance-esg-arbitration/ (Accessed on 05/02/2024).

The 3 pillars of Sustainability: Environmental, Social and Economic., Available at https://www.enel.com/company/stories/articles/2023/06/three-pillars-sustainability (Accessed on 03/02/2024).

United Nations General Assembly., ‘Transforming Our World: the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.’ 21 October 2015, A/RES/70/1., Available at https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/21252030%20Agenda%20for%20Sustainabl e%20Development%20web.pdf (Accessed on 03/02/2024).

United States Environmental Protection Agency., ‘What is Sustainability.’ Available at https://www.epa.gov/sustainability/learn-about-sustainability (Accessed on 03/02/2024).

World Commission on Environment and Development., ‘Our Common Future.’ Oxford, (Oxford University Press, 1987).

Xia, F., Chen, J., Yang, X., Li, X. and Zhang, B., ‘Financial Constraints and Corporate Greenwashing Strategies in China’ (2023) 30 Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management 1770.

Continue Reading

Trending